Welcome
to MrHonda’s mystery hour, where we delve into the unexplained
behaviors of vintage Honda motorcycles, after normal repairs have
been completed. In this edition, the subject in question is a 1969 Honda CL175K3, which had an engine overhaul and carburetor cleaning.
The engine starts up easily but then loads up the spark plugs quickly
with excess fuel.
Spark
plug fouling at idle is generally attributed to either the
wrong-sized pilot jets, high float levels, blocked air bleed
passages at the carburetor inlet ports, incorrect ignition timing,
high resistance spark plug caps, defective spark plugs (fake
reproductions), low spark voltage due to failing coils, weak
condenser, incorrect cam timing or aftermarket parts which are not
made to OEM specifications.
Background
information: The engine was brought to me in pieces for a rebuild,
including the replacement of the kickstarter shaft. The cylinders were
still on STD bore sizes, so the bores were honed and new rings were installed. The original valves were re-seated and all new seals and
gaskets installed. It was pretty much a standard engine rebuild.
Once
installed, the engine was started up, sounding rough as if it was
running very rich at idle and just off-idle. It fuel-fouled the spark
plugs in just a matter of minutes. The carburetors had been
disassembled and cleaned, noting that one of the slide needles were
marked D2, which indicates that they are from Keyster carb kit. The
idle jets were also from the kit and marked #38, which is correct for
this engine series. The main jets were marked #92, which is stock,
but I have had issues with the accuracy of the kit parts in many
cases. The bike is a Scrambler, with left-side high pipes, which have
to be removed or at least loosened up so that the left-side cover,
air filter and carburetor can be removed for service. The carburetors
were inspected several times after each start-up with no favorable
response to any adjustments done to the needle height or float
levels. There was an odd situation where the left side carburetor
fuel levels were greater than the right side, despite careful float
adjustments. The petcock was checked as it was dripping, even in the
OFF position.
The
petcock had been installed without a sealing washer for the
attachment screw that holds the petcock to the bottom of the tank.
Additionally, the back side of the fuel lever was uneven allowing
fuel to pass the barriers of the 4-hole petcock gasket. Once the
fuel lever was flattened out and a sealing washer installed, the
petcock functioned normally. Both fuel lines were matched in length
to alleviate any issues with fuel flow to each carburetor.
Having
removed, cleaned and inspected the OEM carburetors three or four
times, I had to start looking at other associated problems that might
have been overlooked or assembled in error. Starting with the basics,
the compression readings were about 140 psi, which is a bit lower
than Honda’s spec for a normal engine. Low compression readings,
when both sides are the same, can be indications of incorrect cam
timing. This engine had new rings, which were not seated yet, so some
leakage was to be expected. A leak-down test showed nothing abnormal,
apart from some air leaking into the crankcase past the new rings.
All
indications were that the cam timing was correct, although Honda’s
tune up book showed the intake valve opening at 10 degrees before top
dead center, and actual valve opening appeared to be starting at
about 20 degrees. This might look like the cam timing was incorrectly
set, however most cam timing readings are taken at .040” so with
that in mind the cam timing was correct. I actually removed the top
cylinder head cover to verify that the marks were correct, which they
were. So, take that off the list of possibilities.
I
observed that the aftermarket replacement ignition points were
contacting at the very edge of the contact faces, rather than in a
more central location. A bit of bending of the stationary contact
brought the contact back towards the middle. The gap was rechecked
and timing adjusted to suit. The spark advance was checked for
proper function in advance and full retard positions. The ignition
coil was an aftermarket replacement with the original spark plug caps
installed. The caps were measuring about 10k ohms, instead of the
preferred 5k ohms, so were replaced. So far, no “smoking gun” was
found to cause the rich running of what appeared to be stock OEM or
replacement parts.
A
set of aftermarket, Chinese-made carburetors had been brought down
originally, so in desperation, they were installed. These replacement
parts had their own issues. The “set” was actually two right-side carburetor bodies, so that both had the carb adjustment screws on the
right side and fuel feed fittings on the left side. Both carbs had
the same slides with the same cutaways, as that is what a right-side carburetor would be equipped with.
The
carburetors were fitted to the stock intake manifolds which had been
flattened off with my little belt sander to ensure flat contact
surfaces. Once fitted, the bike was started up and immediately ran
cleaner and idled down comfortably without the rich running that was
occurring with the “stock” carburetors. At this point I was
truly baffled about why the stock carbs failed to function properly,
and a set of Chinese carburetors, which had no markings on any of the
jets, were working normally.
However,
the Chinese carburetors had a different issue. The next day, the bike
was hard starting and only ran on almost full choke. As it warmed up,
I slowly lowered the choke lever until it would start to stall out
again, which indicated that the needles needed to be raised up a bit.
The right side needle was a 5 notch type with the clip all the way at
the top.. so super lean. I moved the clip to the middle groove. The
left side needle came out and was a completely different type with
only 3 notches! I went for the full rich option and restarted the
engine again. Like magic, the bike took throttle, off idle, and was
smooth and responsive in a 5-minute test ride.
I
reported this limited success to the owner of the bike project, but
could not give a cause for what had happened… until I went to put
the old carbs into a box for storage.
Looking
carefully at the carb needles, I finally realized that they were of
different material. One was a brass D2 Keyster needle, but the other
silver-colored needle was not marked at all. Comparing the two, the
profiles of the needle tapers were different, as measured with a
caliper. Ah, ha! Maybe I was on to something important, after all.
Then, I flipped over both of the carb slides, which appeared to be
the same, as far as the material and coating was concerned, but then
was shocked to see that one slide was an OEM Honda part and the other
one was not marked at all! Sitting them side-by-side, I could see
that the slide cutaways were a bit different and then looking even
more closely, the whole slide bottom, where the needles are located
were at a different height! The aftermarket slide was a completely
different part, as far as dimensions go for the needle and the
cutaway. Eureka, I found it!
I
was able to track down a set of OEM needles from an eBay seller, then
went to cmsnl.com for the other needle, plus a new OEM slide, plus a
pair of OEM idle jets. I now have confidence that with the correct
OEM parts installed, the stock OEM carburetors should work normally,
as designed. It’s been an arduous task with many hours of removing,
inspecting, cleaning and installing the stock carbs over and over
again, expecting a better result. I think that has been described as
“insanity,” isn’t it?
I
thought that this was the end of the story, however the bike had
other ideas. When the fueling issue seemed to be solved, a long
downhill run, a part of my testing process ended when the bike slowed down for a corner and then went completely DEAD! It had blown
a 20 amp fuse. I had no other fuses with the bike and I was stuck a
mile away on an uphill return. I called a couple of neighbors and
neighbor Paul picked up the phone during his grocery shopping and
said he would come and pick me up shortly.
I
pushed the bike up an angled cement corner, made for wheelchair
access, and left it under the shade of a palm tree. Paul came by,
picked me up and dropped me at home. I loaded up the Tacoma and
headed back down the hill to where the bike awaited my return.
Loading a 280 lb. bike, even with my long ramp into the Tacoma can be
challenging, but when I arrived at the bike a somewhat scruffy man
was sitting next to it, accompanied by his dog. We spoke about the
bike and what had happened. I could tell that he was looking for
signs that this was my bike and I was the rightful recipient of it.
He happily helped me load the bike into the bed of the Tacoma and
walked back to his waiting Honda Accord, with the dog in tow. How
amazing that someone came out of nowhere to help out just when I
needed it the most!
I
unloaded the bike and set to work finding the cause of the short. The
bike only has one fuse, so when it is blown you are completely
inoperable. I have a resetable relay connected to a set of wires
with clips on the end. You can put them on the ends of the fuse
holder and it will click on and off, when a short is present. Of
course, it seemed perfectly fine all of a sudden. I did track down
some worn wire for the rear brake light, which was repaired. Also,
the fuse, in the fuse holder, should have been a short 15A
fuse, but was a longer 20A fuse. The length of the fuse, caused the
ends of the wires that attach to the fuse holder to extend out beyond
the plastic fuse holder. That made them vulnerable to contacting a
grounded frame area and create a dead short. I put a shorter fuse in
the holder and pushed the wire ends into the plastic holder out of
harm’s way. Nothing else was evident, so I turned my attention back
to the carburetors.
On
the next short run, partially down the hill, the bike ran well for
about a minute, then went off on one cylinder. I slipped the clutch
and revved the engine sky-high to try to get it back home again, just
a quarter mile away. After it sat for a moment, it suddenly caught on
again and I nursed it back home again. The problem was that the right
side carburetor was running out of fuel, while the left side was
doing fine. I rechecked the float level with the carb still installed
and looked for any signs that perhaps the float was somehow
contacting something inside and shutting off the fuel flow. I did
another around-the-block test and it started to run on one cylinder
again. No matter what I did, it wouldn’t keep fuel in the right
carb bowl.
I
had already bought another aftermarket petcock, in case there were
problems related to the one that came with the bike. I drained the
tank and removed the petcock. On more careful inspection I noticed
that the two holes that feed the fuel lines to the carburetors were
not on the same level. Wow! Could this be a factor in the fuel feed
issue? The new petcock had a little screen on the reserve port
whereas the original did not. Grasping at straws, I installed the
petcock and hooked everything back up. Again, the fuel wouldn’t
flow into the carb unless the bowl was dropped down and the float
allowed to open the float valve. The replacement petcock had its own problems. The space where the attachment screw is narrowed more than stock so the proper screw gasket (not included with the petcock) doesn't fit! I had to slowly grind down the OD of the gasket so it would fit snugly down and seal the screw head.
A friend suggested that I try
another float bowl. The OEM carb bowls fit right up to the Chinese
copies, but the result was the same. I removed the air filter and the
carb from the studs to have another look at the bowl venting system
and rechecked the float level with the carb held on the side, with
just the weight of the plastic floats touching the needle. The
measurement was different in that angle, so was re-adjusted again to
21mm.
Comparing
the float bowls, I noticed that the brass overflow tube on the
aftermarket carburetor had a really tiny hole. The carb had flooded
over previously, so I knew that the passage was opened. But when I
compared the OEM bowl to the A/M version, the original brass tube had
about a 1.5mm hole vs about half of that on the copy. I opened the
tip of the tube up with my 1.5mm drill bit and put it all back
together once again. I turned on the petcock, waited a minute and
then shut it off and removed the float bowl. It was FULL!
I
re-installed the air filter and side cover and went for a short ride
just to test the performance. It was greatly improved and only hinted
at a big of richness just off-idle. I removed the mismatched
aftermarket needles… yes they were not a match on the same set of
carbs, too! I compared all needles from both carbs and discovered
that the D3 needle was match for the other brass needle and the two
silver needles were also about the same. I dropped the needles down
to the #2 groove and reinstalled them again. Suddenly, the bike felt
and sounded like a almost normal CL175 Honda twin again. I brought my
fuse tester with me, just in case, but made the full downhill test
run back to the place where the fuse had blown before and then turned back
around for the return leg. It was running well; as well as it could
on aftermarket carbs and a mix of non-OEM carb bits.
Bill
M. was on his way down to pick up the CL175 and leave me an XR75,
plus the chassis for the SL100 engine that I had finished rebuilding.
Obviously, I was very pleased to have finally conquered the worst of
the bike’s problems and felt it was safe to drive regularly. I
would feel even better once the OEM carb parts arrived from Holland.
At some point the original carbs can be returned to the engine, for
which they were intended.
I
lost track of the actual hours of work devoted to analyzing and
developing some strategies for a successful outcome. In the end there
is a sense satisfaction that perhaps I learned something new, when
facing similar challenges in the future.
Well,
it certainly had me going round and round, unfortunately overlooking
what was obvious in hindsight. It’s difficult enough to repair
these old bikes given the lack of original parts, here in the 21st
Century. While the aftermarket vendors try to supply the needs of
owners, unfortunately, the lack of quality control and design detail can cause a world of frustration, in cases such as this.
In
situations, such as this, when nothing makes sense, even though you
think that everything has been done correctly, you have to backtrack
and dig deep into the minutiae of the smallest details. A small
discrepancy can derail your best efforts to troubleshoot and diagnose
the problem. In the end, you will find success.
Bill
Silver
aka
MrHonda
www.vintagehonda.com
08/2024